I don't know which side to believe here but it does make me wonder about other things. What if a bird photographer scattered some seeds about; would that make his shots of birds attracted by the seeds unacceptabe as "wildlife" shots? If so, then probably every underwater photo of a shark would be circumspect since they are usually attracted by baiting. What about photographing Bighorn sheep at a natural salt lick? You know they are going to be there. What do others feel about this?

I realize my "what ifs" do not exactly pertain to the subject presented, just wondering what others think.

Wayne