odf opened this issue on Oct 27, 2008 · 13964 posts
kobaltkween posted Fri, 27 February 2009 at 9:26 AM
actually, i've heard that Leonardo had to do a lot of faking to make his diagrams the way he wanted them. he was more interested in mathematical ideals than pure reality. this shows in a lot of Renaissance work in general. i had a course once on visual art and perception, and they showed how lots of things we think of as "correct" in terms of perspective are actually egregiously wrong, but a convention in visual art. and that a lot of correct stuff will look wrong just because certain POVs are generally avoided in media.
if i had to count heads, i'd do it on a photo reference, not based on an art book or an artist's diagrams. a first generation copy is always better than the third or fourth. but then, i think it's much better to acheive realism through being specific and not guessing at "averages," because i think that we (as your average modern citizens) spend much more time looking at manipulated images (and postworked people) than reality and don't have a strong innate notion of average.